Bertrand's Paradox

Compare three answers to Bertrand’s random chord problem and see how the sampling method changes the probability.

Result
—

How to calculate

For uniform endpoints, the favorable arc is one third of the circle. For a midpoint selected uniformly along a radius, favorable midpoints lie in the first half. For a midpoint uniform in the disk, the favorable area is the disk of half the radius, one quarter of the total area.

Worked example

Use Random chord sampling method Two uniform endpoints. The result is ≈ 33.333333333333333333%.

Input and result notes

The event is a chord longer than a side of the inscribed equilateral triangle. The sampling method defines what “random” means.

Mathematical analysis of Bertrand’s paradox

Related calculators